Nat's New York Pizzeria
Salads
House Salad - Large
Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers, and olives.
$13.00
Caesar Salad - Large
Home-made dressing from Nat's New York Pizzeria family recipe tossed with romaine, lettuce, and croutons.
$13.00
Chicken Caesar Salad - Large
$15.50
Greek Salad - Large
Fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, onions, Feta cheese, olives, and Nat's New York Pizzeria dressing.
$13.00
House Salad - X-Large
$15.50
Caesar Salad - X-L
This is THE best Caesar. Period!
$15.50
Chicken Caesar Salad - X-L
The BEST Chicken Caesar salad you'll ever have!
$18.00
Greek Salad - X-L
$15.50
Soup
Mama Rosa's Homemade Chicken Vegetable Soup
$8.50
Heros - the OG sub
Large = 6"; X-Large = Footlong
Cold Eggplant Deluxe - Large
$13.99
Eggplant Parmesan - Large
$17.50
Chicken Cutlet Parmesan - Large
$14.50
Cold Chicken Deluxe - Large
$14.50
Italian Deli Deluxe - Large
$14.50
Veal Cutlet Parmesan - Large
$17.50
Sausage Deluxe Parmesan - Large
$16.99
Meatball Parmesan - Large
$17.50
Cold Eggplant Deluxe - X-Large
$17.50
Eggplant Parmesan - X-Large
$17.50
Chicken Cutlet Parmesan - X-large
$17.99
Cold Chicken Deluxe - X-Large
$17.50
Italian Deli Deluxe - X-Large
$17.99
Veal Cutlet Parmesan - X-Large
$20.99
Pizza - Vegetarian
Large serves 2-3; X-Large serves 3-4
14" Large Margarita Pizza (Cheese)
Nat's New York Pizzeria secret tomato sauce and special mozzarella. Feeds 3 - 4.
$23.50
16" Extra Large Margarita Pizza (Cheese)
Nat's New York Pizzeria secret tomato sauce and special mozzarella. Feeds 4 - 6.
$25.99
14" Large Mushroom Pizza
Lots of thinly sliced mushrooms. Feeds 3 - 4.
$25.99
16" Extra Large Mushroom Pizza
Lots of thinly sliced mushrooms! Feeds 4 - 6.
$28.50
14" Large Spicy Mushroom Pizza
Sliced thick and cooked spicy. Feeds 3 - 4.
$26.50
16" Extra Large Spicy Mushroom Pizza
Sliced thick and cooked spicy. Feeds 4 - 6.
$28.50
14" Large Pesto Artichoke Pizza
Crafted with Nat's New York Pizzeria home-made pesto sauce. Feeds 3 - 4.
$28.50
16" Extra Large Pesto Artichoke Pizza
Crafted with Nat's New York Pizzeria home-made pesto sauce. Feeds 4 - 6.
$31.99
14" Large Hot and Sweet Pizza
Mushrooms, hot bell peppers, and pineapple. Feeds 3 - 4.
$28.50
16" Extra Large Hot and Sweet Pizza
Mushrooms, hot bell peppers, and pineapple. Feeds 4 - 6.
$31.99
14" Large 5th Avenue Pizza
Spinach, fresh tomatoes, sweet onions, and feta cheese. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large 5th Avenue Pizza
Spinach, fresh tomatoes, sweet onions, and feta cheese. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large Hot Veg Pizza
Sun-dried tomatoes, zucchini, mushrooms, and hot bell peppers. Serves 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large Hot Veg Pizza
Sun-dried tomatoes, zucchini, mushrooms, and hot bell peppers. Serves 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large T.O. Salad Pizza
Tomatoes, onions, capers, bocconcini, and fresh garlic. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large T.O. Salad Pizza
Tomatoes, onions, capers, bocconcini, and fresh garlic. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large Kits Italiano Pizza
Broccoli, zucchini, cherry tomatoes, and black olives. Serves 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large Kits Italiano Pizza
Broccoli, zucchini, cherry tomatoes, and black olives. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large The Basic Veg Pizza
Mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, and tomatoes. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large The Basic Veg Pizza
Mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, and tomatoes. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large The Vegan Pizza
Lots of sauce, mushrooms, sweet onions, artichoke, black olives, and fresh garlic. Definitely no cheese.
$29.50
16" Extra Large The Vegan Pizza
Lots of sauce, mushrooms, sweet onions, artichoke, black olives, and fresh garlic. Definitely no cheese.
$29.50
Pizza - Meat Lover
Large serves 2-3; X-Large serves 3-4
14" Large Pepperoni Meat Lover Pizza
Classic New York pizza.
$25.99
16" Extra Large Pepperoni Meat Lover Pizza
Best pep in town! Feeds 4 - 6 people.
$28.50
14" Large The Waikiki Meat Lover Pizza
Ham and pineapple. Feeds 3 - 4 people.
$26.99
16" Extra Large The Waikiki Meat Lover Pizza
Ham and pineapple. Feeds 4 - 6.
$30.50
14" Large Chorizo Mushroom Meat Lover Pizza
Lots of both for a big taste. Feeds 3 - 4.
$27.99
16" Extra Large Chorizo Mushroom Meat Lover Pizza
Lots of both for a big taste. Feeds 4 - 6.
$31.99
14" Large Domino's Meat Lover Pizza
Pepperoni, mushrooms, and bell peppers. Feeds 3 - 4.
$28.50
16" Extra Large Domino's Meat Lover Pizza
Pepperoni, mushrooms, and bell peppers. Feeds 4 - 6.
$32.50
14" Large Meat Deluxe Meat Lover Pizza
Pepperoni, chorizo, mushrooms, onions, red, and green peppers. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large Meat Deluxe Meat Lover Pizza
Pepperoni, chorizo, mushrooms, onions, red, and green peppers. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large Beef Eater Meat Lover Pizza (Feeds 3 - 4 people)
Feta cheese, beef, tomatoes, and onions.
$29.99
16" Extra Large Beef Eater Meat Lover Pizza
Feta cheese, beef, tomatoes, and onions. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large Italian Classic Meat Lover Pizza
Italian sausage, red peppers, Sicilian olives, white onions, and fresh garlic. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large Italian Classic Meat Lover Pizza
Italian sausage, red peppers, Sicilian olives, white onions, and fresh garlic. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large Meat Head Meat Lover Pizza
Salami, ham, and seasoned beef. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large Meat Head Meat Lover Pizza
Salami, ham, and seasoned beef. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large Uncle Tony Meat Lover Pizza
Salami, white onions, anchovies, and fresh garlic. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large Uncle Tony Meat Lover Pizza
Salami, white onions, anchovies, and fresh garlic. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large Uncle Al Meat Lover Pizza
Hot capicollo, hot bell peppers, sweet onions, and roasted garlic. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large Uncle Al Meat Lover Pizza
Hot capicollo, hot bell peppers, sweet onions, and roasted garlic. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
14" Large Uncle Joe Meat Lover Pizza
Anchovies, fresh tomatoes, sweet onions, and fresh garlic. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large Uncle Joe Meat Lover Pizza
Anchovies, fresh tomatoes, sweet onions, and fresh garlic. Feeds 4 - 6.
$33.50
Speciality Pizzas
Large serves 2-3; X-Large serves 3-4
14" Large Pizza Bianca
Olive oil, broccoli, four cheese, red peppers, and Kalamata olives. Feeds 3 - 4.
$30.99
16" Extra Large Pizza Bianca
Olive oil, broccoli, four cheese, red peppers, and Kalamata olives. Feeds 4 - 6.
$35.99
14" Large N.Y. Deli Specialty Pizza
Capicollo, ham, pepperoni, and salami. Feeds 3 - 4.
$30.99
16" Extra Large N.Y. Deli Specialty Pizza
Capicollo, ham, pepperoni, and salami. Feeds 4 - 6.
$35.99
14" Large BBQ Chicken Specialty Pizza (Feeds 3 - 4 people)
Ranch, olive oil, sweet onions, bell peppers with Nat's BBQ sauce.
$30.99
16" Extra Large BBQ Chicken Specialty Pizza
Ranch, olive oil, sweet onions, bell peppers with Nat's BBQ sauce.
$31.20
14" Large Maui Wowie Specialty Pizza
BBQ chicken, ham, peppers, onions, and pineapple. Feeds 3 - 4.
$30.99
16" Extra Large Maui Wowie Specialty Pizza
BBQ chicken, ham, peppers, onions, and pineapple. Feeds 4 - 6.
$35.99
14" Large The Hilton "That's Hot" Specialty Pizza
Hot capicollo, hot bell peppers, and spicy mushrooms. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large The Hilton "That's Hot" Specialty Pizza
Hot capicollo, hot bell peppers, and spicy mushrooms. Feeds 4 - 6.
$35.99
14" Large El Taco Specialty Pizza
Seasoned beef with shredded lettuce, diced tomato, olives, mozzarella, cheddar, and chives. Ask for ranch dressing. Feeds 3 - 4.
$29.99
16" Extra Large El Taco Specialty Pizza
Seasoned beef with shredded lettuce, diced tomato, olives, mozzarella, cheddar, and chives. Ask for ranch dressing. Feeds 4 - 6.
$36.20
Pasta
Spaghetti in Marinara Sauce - Large
Home-made tomato sauce! Yum!
$14.99
Penne in Marinara Sauce - Large
Tomato sauce.
$14.99
Spaghetti with Olive Oil and Garlic - Large
$13.99
Penne in Olive Oil and Garlic - Large
$13.99
Penne and Broccoli - Large
In butter garlic sauce.
$16.99
Baked Penne
$18.99
Spaghetti Primavera - Large
With mushrooms, broccoli, and peppers.
$16.99
Penne Primavera - Large
With mushrooms, broccoli, and peppers.
$16.99
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce - large
In bolognese (meat sauce).
$17.50
Penne with Meat Sauce - Large
In bolognese (meat sauce).
$17.50
Spaghetti and Meatballs - Large
$17.50
Spaghetti and Sausage - Large
$17.50
Traditional Lasagna
$21.99
Baked Penne with Meat Sauce - Large
In bolognese (meat sauce).
$17.50
Spaghetti in Marinara Sauce - X-Large
Home-made tomato sauce! Yum!
$17.99
Penne in Marinara Sauce - X-Large
$17.99
Spaghetti in Olive Oil and Garic - X-Large
$15.99
Sides
Garlic Bread
$2.25
Meatballs - X-Large
$15.00
Sausages
$10.34
Footlong Cheese Bread
$10.34
Footlong Pepperoni and Cheese Bread
$11.64
Beverages
Can of Pop
Dr. Pepper, Mug Rootbeer, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi
$2.50
Bottle of Pop
Crush Cream Soda - Grape Crush - Orange Crush, Dr. Pepper, Gingerale, Mountain Dew, Dad's Cream Soda, Dad's Root Beer, 7-up