Formaggio's Pie Shack
Place Settings
Please list the number of place settings that you'd like, along with your order.
Appetizers.
Pepper Poppers (6 pcs)
Fresh jalapeno peppers stuffed with a two cheese and bacon blend, then baked to perfection. One order comes with six pieces.
$9.85
Stuffed Caps (6 pcs)
Six hearty mushroom caps filled with Formaggio's Pie Shack cream cheese and bacon blend, then baked to a golden brown.
$9.85
Three Cheese Garlic Ranch Flatbread
It comes with a mixture of quality mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, and fresh Parmesan cheese toasted to a golden brown over Formaggio's Pie Shack garlic ranch sauce on freshly baked flatbread.
$15.96
BBQ Chicken Flatbread
Grilled chicken, bacon, green peppers, red onions, shredded cheddar cheese on Formaggio's Pie Shack barbeque sauce layered on freshly baked flatbread.
$17.20
Bruschetta Flatbread
A mixture of fresh basil, feta cheese and Formaggio's Pie Shack tomato/balsamic, olive oil, and herb mixture on a freshly baked flatbread.
$15.96
Onion Rings
Thick sliced onions battered and deep fried... no kissing after!
$9.30
French Fries
Sometimes, you need a plate of fries to make your day right!
$7.75
Poutine
Our fries heaped with loads of mozzarella and Formaggio's Pie Shack in house gravy.
$14.25
Stuffed Pickles
It comes with two of our extra-large stubbs pickles sliced and loaded with a blend of cheese and bacon. One order comes with 4 slices.
$9.90
Combo Platter
For when you just can't decide, the combo platter includes two pepper poppers, two stuffed caps, and two stuffed pickles.
$10.25
Regular Garlic Bread
The Original. Ciabatta bread with heaps of garlic butter and fresh parsley.
$6.95
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Ciabatta bread with heaps of garlic butter and fresh parsley, plus a two cheese blend piled high on top.
$10.95
Mama's Nachos
Your choice of chicken or beef loaded with heaps of cheddar and mozzarella cheese, and topped with onion, tomato, green peppers, hot peppers. This is served with salsa and sour cream on the side for dipping.
$21.00
Salads.
Caesar Salad
Fresh Romaine lettuce, real bacon, fresh Parmesan cheese, and garlic croutons tossed with creamy garlic dressing.
$6.00
Greek Salad
Fresh romaine, tomatoes, black olives, red onion, cucumber, and crumbled feta cheese tossed with traditional greek dressing.
$6.00
Summertime Salad
A mix of fresh baby spinach and romaine, mandarin oranges, almond slivers and crumbled feta in creamy poppyseed dressing.
$6.00
Sandwiches And Wraps.
All of Formaggio's Pie Shack sammy's and wraps are served with French fries and a strubbs pickle slice.
The Spicy Sammy Sandwich
Hot Italian sausage and salami topped with mozzarella cheese and Formaggio's Pie Shack famous spicy tomato sauce on a freshly toasted ciabatta bun.
$15.00
The Chicken Club Sandwich
Sliced grilled chicken breast, bacon, tomato, lettuce, and cheddar cheese piled high on toasted ciabatta bread with a slather of chipotle mayo.
$15.95
The Meatball Sammy Sandwich
Our homemade meatballs, Formaggio’s tomato sauce and a healthy helping of fresh parmesan cheese served up on a toasted fresh panini bun.
$14.75
Big Boy Grilled Cheese and Bacon Sandwich
Toasted ciabatta bun loaded with a blend of cheddar and mozzarella cheese, and a stack of bacon.
$14.75
Beef Dip
Shave prime ribeye steak layered on a fresh bun and served with a warm au jus for dipping.
$15.95
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Deep fried chicken tossed in Formaggio's Pie Shack medium hot sauce, fresh lettuce and cheddar cheese wrapped up tight in a large tortilla shell.
$14.50
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Choose sliced grilled chicken or deep fried chicken, bacon, lettuce, and fresh parmesan cheese with creamy caesar salad dressing wrapped in a large tortilla shell.
$14.50
Greek Wrap
Grilled chicken, black olives, tomato, onion, romaine lettuce, and crumbled feta cheese wrapped in a large tortilla shell.
$14.25
Veggie Wrap
Fresh lettuce, tomato, cucumber, green pepper, and onion wrapped in a large tortilla shell.
$11.20
Wings, Fingers and Fish.
Pie Shack Wings
1 lb of jumbo wings…get them baked or deep fried.
$16.60
Boneless Wings
1 lb of deep fried boneless wings.
$16.60
Boneless Wings and Fries
1/2 lb of deep fried boneless wings with fries.
$15.75
Chicken Fingers and Fries
Five tender chicken fingers with fries and plum sauce.
$15.75
Haddock and Chips
So popular as a special, we added it to the menu! Perfectly battered and deep fried haddock served with a generous helping of Formaggio's Pie Shack tartar sauce, lemon wedge, and fries.
$16.25
Burgers.
Formaggio's Pie Shack burgers are topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and onion and served with french fries and a strubbs pickle slice.
Formaggio's Burger
A juicy, 6 oz all beef burger. Choose your toppings and enjoy!
$15.95
Chicken Burger
Formaggio's Pie Shack deep fried chicken burger will hit the spot! Choose your toppings to make it just right!
$15.95
Pasta.
Don't see what you want? Formaggio's Pie Shack will do their best to personalize your pasta!
Spaghetti And Meatballs
Formaggio’s marinara sauce coupled with Formaggio's Pie Shack homemade meatballs served over traditional spaghetti.
$15.25
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Sliced chicken breast, fresh mushrooms and roasted red peppers combined with our creamy alfredo sauce, served on top of a bed of classic fettuccine noodles.
$16.25
Three Cheese Ravioli
Cheese stuffed ravioli with Formaggio’s traditional marinara sauce, loaded with a cheddar, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese blend, then baked just the perfect amount to lightly crisp the cheese.
$15.75
Penne Plus Three
Choose your sauce (marinara or alfredo) and choose your three toppings served over penne noodles. More than three toppings are at additional cost, but we are sure your creation will be worth it!
$15.25
Pizza Deals.
Two Pizza Deals (Two Medium Three-Topping Pizzas)
Two medium pizzas with three regular toppings.
$38.50
Two Pizza Deals (Two Large Three-Topping Pizzas)
Two large pizzas with three regular toppings.
$46.00
Two Pizza Deals (Two X-Large Three-Topping Pizzas)
Two extra-large pizzas with three regular toppings.
$62.50
Two Pizza Deals (Two Medium Three-Topping Gluten-Friendly Pizzas)
Two medium gluten-friendly pizzas with three regular toppings.
$36.52
The Family Deal
Large three-topping pizza, Caesar salad, and three pieces of garlic bread.
$44.00
Game Night Deal
Extra large three regular topping pizza and loaded nachos (chicken or beef).
$45.00
Panzerotti Deal
Large three-topping panzerotti and Caesar salad.
$31.00
Pizza and Chicken Wing Deal
Medium three-topping pizza and ten pieces of jumbo chicken wings.
$36.72
Deep-Dish Pizzas.
All the same fresh ingredients Formaggio uses for the other pizzas, but more of it and piled higher!
Personal Deeeeep Dish Pizza (1 lb)
$20.25
Medium Deeeeep Dish Pizza (3 lbs)
$40.71
Large Deeeeep Dish Pizza (5 lbs)
$45.10
Create Your Own Pizzas.
You are the chef with each and every one of the pizzas! Create an endless combo of unique favourites!
Personal Three-Topping Pizza
Personal pizza with your choice of three regular toppings.
$15.25
Medium Three-Topping Pizza
Medium pizza with your choice of three regular toppings.
$23.25
Large Three-Topping Pizza
Large pizza with your choice of three regular toppings.
$27.50
X-Large Three-Topping Pizza
Extra-large pizza with your choice of three regular toppings.
$35.50
Medium Three-Topping Gluten-Friendly Pizza
Gluten friendly pizza with your choice of three regular toppings.
$23.00
Panzerotti.
You’ve had this before, but now it’s time to try Formaggio's! Baked to golden perfection, never fried!
Regular Three-Topping Panzerotti
Unlike traditional panzerottis, Formaggio's Pie Shack's crispy golden pillows are baked instead of fried. Just like Formaggio's Pie Shack's pizza, you choose from one of Formaggio's Pie Shack's homemade sauces and three regular toppings. Served up with a generous portion of marinara sauce for dipping.
$22.00
Large Three-Topping Panzerotti
Unlike traditional panzerottis, Formaggio's Pie Shack's crispy golden pillows are baked instead of fried. Just like Formaggio's Pie Shack's pizza, you choose from one of Formaggio's Pie Shack's homemade sauces and three regular toppings. Served up with a generous portion of marinara sauce for dipping.