Connie and John's Pizza
Popular Items
Check out the most popular items on the menu.
John’s Pepperoni Pizza
House made pepperoni, San Marzano tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.
See Item
Formaggio The Grate Pizza
All cheese pizza, mozzarella, provolone, and cheddar.
See Item
The Roni Cup Pizza
Pepperoni, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese.
$33.95
Jersey Joe’s Margherita Pizza
Tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and basil.
See Item
Fun Guy Pizza
Three cheese, lots of mushrooms, and truffle olive oil.
See Item
Snack and Salad
Our Caesar Salad
Chopped garden kale, bacon, fresh grated parmesan cheese, toasted focaccia crumb, lemon and olive oil, creamy dressing
See Item
9 Spiced Chicken Wings (10 pcs)
Nine spiced chicken wings with your heat level hot, medium, or mild. One order comes with ten pieces. Gluten Friendly
$16.95
Deep Dish Garlic Cheesy Breadsticks (8" x 10")
Crispy cheddar crust, herb and garlic mozzarella
Round Pizza
John’s Pepperoni Pizza
House made pepperoni, San Marzano tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.
See Item
Jersey Joe’s Margherita Pizza
Tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and basil.
See Item
Fun Guy Pizza
Three cheese, lots of mushrooms, and truffle olive oil.
See Item
Island Pie Pizza
Shaved Italian ham, mozzarella, and pineapple.
See Item
What We Eat Pizza
Ham, pepperoni, chilies, and a lot of cheese.
See Item
Formaggio The Grate Pizza
All cheese pizza, mozzarella, provolone, and cheddar.
See Item
16" Feature Round Pizza Half and Half
Half John’s Pepperoni and Half Formaggio The Grate Pizza
$32.95
Half Island Pie and Half Formaggio The Grate Pizza
$32.95
Square Pizza 14” x 10” Detroit Deep Pizza
The Roni Cup Pizza
Pepperoni, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese.
$33.95
Cheesy Brick Pizza
We can't add any more cheese!
$31.95
Connie’s Loaded Pizza
Ham, pepperoni, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese.
$34.95
Maui Waui
Shaved ham, smoked bacon crumble, pineapple, hot chilies
$33.95
Combos
Bundle for 2-4: one 16" NYC Pizza, a Crusty Dip, choice of CHAR Caesar Salad or 9 Spice Chicken Wings
Bundle for two comes with one 16" NYC Big round pizza, choice of crusty dip, and your choice of Char Caesar salad or 9 spice chicken wings.
$46.95
Bundle for 4-6: one 16" NYC Pizza, 9 Spiced Chicken Wings, CHAR Caesar Salad, Garlic and Cheese Bread Sticks, a Crusty Dip
Bundle for four comes with your choice of 16" New Big round pizza, 9 spice chicken wings, Char Caesar salad, garlic and cheese breadsticks, and a choice of crusty dip.
$72.95
Bundle for 6-8: two 16" NYC Pizzas, 3 Crusty Dips, 2 orders of 9 Spice Chicken Wings, Chocolate Chip Cookies
Combo for six comes with your choice of two 16" NYC Big round pizzas, pickled chilies, house herb aioli, marinara sauce, two orders of 9 spice chicken wings, and a Connie & John's chocolate chip cookies.
$99.75
Crusty Dips
Marinara Dip
$2.95
House Herb Aioli
$2.95
Picked Chili's Dip
$2.95
Drinks
Boylans Craft Sodas
$4.75
Root Beer
$4.75
Cream Soda
$4.75
Orange
$4.75
Cola
$4.75
Bottle Water
$2.75
Black Cherry
$4.75
Dessert
Connie & John's S'mores Cookie
$5.00
Place Settings
Please list the number of place settings that you'd like, along with your order.