Sweetie Pie

New

1639 Bayview Ave, East York, ON M4G 3B5, Canada

Opens at 9:30 AM

More

Community Support

Local restaurants are the heart, soul, and stomach of our communities. In this challenging time, you can support your favourite hometown heroes with a restaurant tip. 100% of this added contribution will go to your selected restaurant.

  • Contribute Now

    See Item

Place Settings

Please list the number of place settings that you’d like, along with your order.

  • Number of Plastic Cutlery

    How many people will be eating from this order?

    See Item

Sweet Pies

  • Apple Pie (9 Inch)

    Sweetie Pie's blend of tart and sweet, crunchy apples perfectly tossed in brown sugar with a bit of cinnamon, nutmeg, and real vanilla will make you...

    $26.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Pecan Pie (8 Inch)

    Nothing is better than warm old-fashioned pecan pie. Order this handcraft and locally source taste of heaven today. All Sweetie Pie's pies are made...

    $28.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Blueberry Pie (9 Inch)

    Nothing is better than warm blueberry pie. Order this handcraft, locally-sourced taste of heaven today. All Sweetie Pie's pies are made with love by...

    $26.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Sweet Dark Cherry Pie (9 Inch)

    Made with locally-sourced ingredients, Sweetie Pie's cherry pies are handcrafted every morning by their in-house pastry chefs.

    $26.99

  • Pumpkin Pie (9 Inch)

    $26.99

Sweet Pies (5 Inch)

  • MenuItemImage
    Apple Pie (5 Inch)

    Sweetie Pie's blend of tart and sweet, crunchy apples perfectly tossed in brown sugar with a bit of cinnamon, nutmeg, and real vanilla will make you...

    $8.99

  • Pecan Pie (5 Inch)

    Nothing is better than warm old-fashioned pecan pie. Order this handcraft and locally source taste of heaven today. All Sweetie Pie's pies are made...

    $9.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Blueberry Pie (5 Inch)

    Nothing is better than warm blueberry pie. Order this handcraft, locally-sourced taste of heaven today. All Sweetie Pie's pies are made with love by...

    $8.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Sweet Dark Cherry Pie (5 Inch)

    Made with locally-sourced ingredients, Sweetie Pie's cherry pies are handcrafted every morning by their in-house pastry chefs.

    $8.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Pumpkin Pie (5 Inch)

    $8.99

Savory Pies (5 Inch)

  • Steak and Ale (5 Inch)

    A classic pub style pie with slow-cooked beef, potatoe, and stout beer.

    $8.99

  • Pulled Pork Pie (5 Inch)

    Pulled pork flavored with Sweetie Pie's chef's special Texas-style barbecue sauce.

    $8.99

  • Spicy Beef Curry Pie (5 Inch)

    Spicy minced beef flavoured with a house-made blend of Indian spices.

    $8.99

  • Braised Beef Short Rib Pie (5 Inch)

    Filled with tender slow-cooked beef in rich red wine gravy.

    $8.99

  • Chicken Pot Pie (5 Inch)

    A home-style classic, chicken in a creamy gravy with peas and carrots.

    $8.99

  • Vegan Mushroom Pot Pie (5 Inch)

    An innovative twist on the classic - with a rich velouté.

    $8.99

Crazy Good Cakes

All cakes are served in a pack of four pieces.

  • MenuItemImage
    Carrot Cake (4 pcs)

    Carrot cake,(250 ml) each. Yummy, yummy crazy good cake! This perfectly-sized jar is packed full of deliciousness and layered with and ever so silky...

    $24.99

  • Red Velvet Cake (4 pcs)

    Red velvet cake, (250 ml) each. Yummy, yummy crazy good cake! This perfectly-sized jar is packed full of deliciousness and layered with ever so silky...

    $24.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Birthday Cake (4 pcs)

    Birthday cake, (250 ml) each piece. Yummy, yummy crazy good cake! This perfectly-sized jar is packed full of deliciousness and layered with ever so...

    $24.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Chocolate Fudge (4 pcs)

    Pack of four. Chocolate fudge cake 250 ml each.

    $24.99

    MenuItemImage

Baked Speciality Items

All baked specialty items are served in a pack of four pieces.

  • Brownies (4 pcs)

    OMG. Sweetie Pie's brownies are to die for!!! made with a chewy top layer and a warm gooey center it is the perfect treat. One order comes with four...

    $15.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Cinnabuns (4 pcs)

    Come and check out sweetie pie buns !! Fresh out of the oven every day our oversized Cinnamon Buns oozing with a warm cinnamon center and just the...

    $15.99

  • Date Squares (4 pcs)

    Made with sweet pitted dates, our Date Squares have the right balance out the sweetness with a warm crunchy texture. At Sweetie Pie we make sure...

    $24.99

  • Butter Tarts (4 pcs)

    Nothing tart about Sweet Pie's yummy butter tarts. Made in-house daily. It is impossible to have one. One order comes with four pieces of butter tart...

    $11.99

    MenuItemImage

Cookies

All cookies are served in a pack of six pieces.

  • Nutella Stuffed Cookies

    $18.00