New Yorker Deli

9.4

1140 Bay St, Toronto, ON M5S 2Z4, Canada

Opens at 9:00 AM

More

Community Support

Local restaurants are the heart, soul, and stomach of our communities. In this challenging time, you can support your favourite hometown heroes with a restaurant tip. 100% of this added contribution will go to your selected restaurant.

  • Contribute Now

    See Item

Place Settings

Please list the number of place settings that you’d like, along with your order.

  • Number of Plastic Cutlery

    How many people will be eating from this order?

    $0.75

All Day Breakfast

  • MenuItemImage
    Fried Egg Sandwich with Bacon

    Fried egg sandwich with bacon served with home fries and toast.

    $10.50

  • Eggs (3)

    One order comes with three eggs and served with home fries and toast.

    $10.49

  • Bacon and Eggs

    Bacon and eggs served with home fries and toast.

    $13.50

  • Sausage and Eggs

    Sausage and eggs served with home fries and toast.

    $13.50

  • Ham and Eggs

    Ham and eggs served with home fries and toast.

    $13.50

  • Peameal Bacon and Eggs

    Peameal bacon and eggs served with home fries and toast.

    Sold Out

  • Corned Beef Hash and Eggs

    Corned beef hash and eggs served with home fries and toast.

    $13.50

  • Steak and Eggs

    Steak and eggs served with home fries and toast.

    $15.95

  • Corned Beef and Eggs

    Corned beef and eggs served with home fries and toast.

    $15.95

  • Salami and Eggs

    Salami and eggs served with home fries and toast.

    $14.45

  • Lox, Onions, and Eggs

    Lox, onions, and eggs, served with home fries and toast.

    $15.95

  • Eggs Benedict

    Eggs Benedict served with home fries.

    Sold Out

  • Eggs Benedict with Smoked Salmon

    Eggs Benedict with smoked salmon served with home fries.

    $15.95

  • Eggs Benedict with Roast Beef

    Eggs Benedict with roast beef served with home fries.

    $15.95

  • Eggs Benedict with Corned Beef

    Eggs Benedict with corned beef served with home fries.

    $15.95

  • Florentine

    Florentine served with home fries and toast.

    $14.95

  • Western Sandwich

    Western sandwich is served with home fries.

    $11.95

    MenuItemImage
  • New Yorker Sandwich

    Scrambled eggs, melted cheddar, and peameal. Served with home fries and toast.

    $12.50

  • Fried Egg Sandwich

    Fried egg sandwich served with home fries and toast.

    $8.50

  • Texas Breakfast

    Three eggs, bacon, sausage, peameal, and beans. Served with home fries and toast.

    $15.25

    MenuItemImage
  • French Toast

    $7.75

    MenuItemImage
  • Cream Cheese Bagel

    $7.95

  • Lox and Cream Cheese Bagel

    $12.50

    MenuItemImage
  • Granola Fruit and Yogurt

    $11.75

  • Cheese Omelette

    Cheese omelette served with home fries and toast.

    $13.50

  • Veggie and Cheese Omelette

    Veggie and cheese omelette served with home fries and toast.

    $15.95

    MenuItemImage
  • Western Omelette

    Western omelette served with home fries and toast.

    $14.95

  • Greek Omelette

    Greek omelette served with home fries and toast.

    $15.50

  • Corned Beef Western Omelette

    Corned beef western omelette served with home fries and toast.

    $15.95

  • Mish Mash Omelette

    Wieners, fried onions, and cheese. Served with home fries and toast.

    $15.95

Appetizers

  • MenuItemImage
    Beef Knish

    Savoury ground beef surrounded by deep-fried potato, served with gravy

    $8.25

  • Chopped Liver with Bagel Chips and Fried Onions

    $10.50

    MenuItemImage
  • Kishka

    $8.25

  • Potato Latkes

    Four potato pancakes served with sour cream

    $7.75

    MenuItemImage
  • Poutine

    $7.75

Soups

  • MenuItemImage
    Cup Cabbage Borscht

    Sweet and savoury beef and cabbage soup

    $6.95

  • Cup of Chicken Noodle Soup

    $6.95

    MenuItemImage
  • Matzo Ball Soup

    $8.95

    MenuItemImage
  • Cup of Kreplach

    $6.95

  • Bowl of Chicken Noodle

    $7.95

  • Bowl Cabbage Borscht

    Sweet and savoury beef and cabbage soup

    $8.95

  • Bowl of Kreplach

    $8.95

  • Litre of Matzo Ball

    $11.99

    MenuItemImage
  • Litre Chicken Noodle

    $11.99

  • Litre Cabbage Borscht

    Sweet and savoury beef and cabbage soup

    $13.99

    MenuItemImage

Salad Bowls

  • MenuItemImage
    Garden Salad

    $13.95

  • Spinach Salad

    $13.75

  • Caesar Salad

    $12.95

  • Greek Salad

    $14.95

  • Deli Salad

    $18.50

  • Cobb Salad

    $18.50

Burgers

  • Burger (1/2 lb) with Fries

    One order comes with a half-pound patty and served with fries.

    $13.50

  • Brisket Burger (1/2 lb)

    Brisket burger comes with a half-pound patty, caramelized onions, cheddar cheese, and dill and horseradish mayo. Served with fries.

    $14.50

That's a Wrap

  • MenuItemImage
    Chicken Caesar Wrap

    $10.75

  • Roast Brisket of Beef Wrap

    $10.75

  • Turkey Wrap

    $10.75

  • Chicken Wrap

    $10.75

  • Corned Beef Wrap

    $10.75

  • Pastrami Wrap

    $10.75

  • Smoked Meat Wrap

    $10.75

  • Club House Wrap

    $10.95

  • B.L.T. Wrap

    $10.75

  • Greek Chicken Wrap

    $10.75

    MenuItemImage
  • Mediterranean Wrap

    Mediterranean wrap with grilled chicken and hummus.

    $10.75

  • Lox and Cream Cheese Wrap

    $10.75

  • Roast Beef Reuben Wrap

    $10.95

  • Pastrami Reuben Wrap

    $10.95

  • Smoked Turkey Reuben Wrap

    $10.95

Dairy and Deli Bar

All sandwiches are served on rye or challah unless specified otherwise

  • MenuItemImage
    Corned Beef

    Served on fresh rye, with mustard

    $10.50

  • Pastrami

    Served on fresh rye, with mustard

    $10.50

    MenuItemImage
  • Smoked Meat

    Served on fresh rye, with mustard

    $10.50

    MenuItemImage
  • Roast Brisket of Beef

    Served on fresh rye, with mustard

    $10.50

    MenuItemImage
  • Salami

    $10.50

  • Smoked Turkey

    $10.50

  • Fresh Roasted Turkey

    $10.50

  • Grilled Chicken Breast

    $10.50

  • Chopped Liver

    $10.50

  • Ham and Cheese

    $10.50

  • Chicken Salad

    $10.50

  • Tuna Salad

    $10.50

  • Sockeye Salmon

    $10.50

  • Egg Salad

    $9.95

  • Hot Meatloaf Sandwich and Fries

    Served on a fresh bun, with gravy, and fries

    $12.25

  • Grilled Cheese and Fries

    $9.25

  • Grilled Cheese and Bacon

    $11.50

  • B.L.T. and Fries

    $10.95

  • Hot Dog and Fries

    $8.95

  • Chicken Fingers and Fries

    $10.75

  • Corned Beef Hash Sandwich and Fries

    Served on toasted ten grain with red onion

    $9.95

  • Wieners and Beans with Fries

    $13.95

Splendid Things

All items are served with your choice of french fries, latkes, home fries, or mashed potatoes, as well as coleslaw, and dill pickles.

  • Deli Platter

    Deli platter comes with your choice of three meats.

    $21.95

    MenuItemImage
  • Filet of Sole and Chips

    $12.25

  • Hot Turkey Dinner

    $17.25

  • Hot Beef Dinner

    $17.25

  • Meatloaf Dinner

    $16.99

  • Corned Beef and Cabbage

    $17.25

  • Chicken Pot Pie

    $13.95

Mr. Twister Bagel Platters

  • MenuItemImage
    Triple Scoop Bagel Platter

    $17.95

  • Chicken Salad Bagel Platter

    $12.95

    MenuItemImage
  • Sockeye Salmon Bagel Platter

    $14.95

  • Albacore Tuna Bagel Platter

    $13.95

  • Egg Salad Bagel Platter

    $12.50

  • Chopped Liver Bagel Platter

    $13.25

    MenuItemImage
  • Smoked Salmon and Cream Cheese Bagel Platter

    $17.25

Box Specials

  • Cup of Soup and Sandwich

    $15.95

    MenuItemImage
  • Matzo Ball and Sandwich

    $16.75

  • Soup and Salad

    $16.75

  • Beef Knish and Sandwich

    $18.95

  • Sandwich and Salad

    $16.95

Combo Sandwiches

All sandwich combos are served with coleslaw, dill pickles, and your choice of french fries, side latkes, or side home fries.

  • MenuItemImage
    Corned Beef Sandwich Combo

    Served on fresh rye, with mustard, and your choice of side

    $16.50

  • Smoked Meat Sandwich Combo

    Served on fresh rye, with mustard, and your choice of side

    $16.50

  • Pastrami Sandwich Combo

    Served on fresh rye, with mustard, and your choice of side

    $16.50

    MenuItemImage
  • Tuna Melt Sandwich Combo

    Served open-faced, on a bagel, with melted cheddar

    $16.50

    MenuItemImage
  • Corned Beef and Swiss Sandwich Combo

    Served on fresh rye, with mustard, and your choice of side

    $16.75

  • Corned Beef and Smoked Turkey Sandwich Combo

    Served on fresh rye, with mustard, and your choice of side

    $16.75

  • Corned Beef, Coleslaw, and Sweet Red Pepper on an Onion Bun Sandwich Combo

    Served on a fresh onion bun, with mustard, and your choice of side

    $16.75

    MenuItemImage
  • Roast Beef Dip with Onions and Peppers Sandwich Combo

    Served on a fresh bun, and your choice of side

    $16.75

    MenuItemImage
  • Reuben Sandwich Combo

    Served on toasted dark rye, with pastrami, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing , with your choice of side

    $16.75

    MenuItemImage
  • Black Forest Ham with Grilled Vegetables and Cheddar Sandwich Combo

    $16.75

  • Grilled Chicken with Grilled Vegetables and Cheddar Sandwich Combo

    Served on toasted ten grain, with your choice of side

    $16.75

    MenuItemImage
  • Club House Sandwich Combo

    Served on toasted white, with chicken, bacon, mayo, lettuce and tomato. With your choice of side.

    $16.75

    MenuItemImage
  • Carnegie Sandwich Combo

    For those who have the appetite.

    $18.95

On the Sides

  • French Fries

    $5.50

  • Home Fries

    $5.50

  • Mashed Potatoes

    $5.50

  • Onion Rings

    $5.50

  • Grilled Veggies

    $5.75

    MenuItemImage
  • Potato Salad

    $3.75

  • Coleslaw

    $3.75

  • Sweet Peppers

    $2.00

  • Hot Peppers

    $2.00

  • Sweet Potato Fries

    $5.95

  • Dill Tomatoes

    $2.00

  • Gravy

    $1.50

  • Sour Cream

    $1.00

  • Cream Cheese

    $2.75

  • Bacon

    $4.95

  • Sausage

    $4.95

Thirst Quenchers

  • Milk

    $2.65

  • Juice

    $2.65

  • Canned Pop

    $2.65

  • Freshly Squeezed Juices

    $4.95

  • Iced Tea

    $3.50

  • Stewarts

    $3.50

  • Milkshakes

    $5.95

  • Coffee

    $2.95

Buy The Pound

  • Corned Beef by the Pound

    $25.95

  • Pastrami by the Pound

    $25.95

  • Smoked Meat by the Pound

    $25.95

  • Roast Brisket of Beef by the Pound

    $26.95

  • Smoked Turkey by the Pound

    $24.95

  • Oven Roasted Turkey by the Pound

    $25.95

  • White Albacore Tuna by the Pound

    $17.96

  • Cole Slaw by the Pound

    $7.50

  • Potato Salad by the Pound

    $7.50

Desserts

  • Rugelach

    Chocolate, raspberry, or raisin.

    $1.75

    MenuItemImage

Jarred Soups & Pickles

Our selection of soups, in one litre mason jars **SOUPS ARE COLD FROM OUR REFRIGERATED SECTION*, as well as a selection of Putter's Pickled products

  • MenuItemImage
    Chicken in a Pot

    Chicken soup with matzo ball and chicken

    $14.00

  • Matzo Ball

    $12.00

    MenuItemImage
  • Split Pea

    $12.00

  • Turkey Barley

    $12.00

  • Beef Barley

    $12.00

  • Lentil

    $12.00

  • Cabbage Borscht

    $14.00

    MenuItemImage
  • Putter's Dill Pickles

    $7.50

  • Putter's Dill Tomatoes

    $8.50

  • Putter's Sweet Pimentos

    $7.50

  • Putter's Banana Peppers

    Spicy

    $7.50

Chips

  • Miss Vickies Salt and Vinegar

    $2.00

  • Miss Vickies Original

    $2.00